Free MLB Picks Today – MLB Best Bets For Thursday, September 18 2025
We cashed 2 of 3 last night and now shift focus to Thursday’s MLB slate with plenty of confidence. Today’s schedule offers no shortage of betting opportunities, and we’ve zeroed in on three games that stand out. With pitching dynamics, lineup form, and key matchup angles in play, these best bets are lined up to keep the momentum rolling and add more profit to the bankroll. It’s time to press the edge and keep cashing tickets on the diamond.
Below, let's take a look at some of my favorite MLB picks for today, in best bets form.
MLB Best Bets Begin With Strong Totals Play
Tonight’s Angels-Brewers matchup at American Family Field leans heavily toward a low-scoring outcome, making the Under 8 a sharp play. Milwaukee sends out Quinn Priester (13–2, 3.25 ERA), who’s been consistently effective with nine quality starts and a .241 opponent batting average, while the Angels counter with Yusei Kikuchi (6–11, 4.08 ERA), who’s held the Brewers to a 3.00 ERA across his career.
Los Angeles ranks 29th in hits and 25th in runs scored, and despite their power, they’ve struggled to string together rallies—especially on the road. The Brewers have gone under the total in four of their last seven home games, and with both starters capable of working deep into the game, expect a controlled tempo and limited scoring chances. A 4–2 final feels well within reach. For a 2nd opinion, check out our Angels vs Brewers prediction.
Sign Up for StatSalt News Alerts, Get Free Picks and Discounts
Subscribe Now
Best Bet#1
- Angels/Brewers Under 8
A Mile High Totals Best Bet
Today’s Marlins-Rockies matchup at Coors Field is tailor-made for a high-scoring affair, making the Over 10 a strong play. With Sandy Alcantara (5.53 ERA) and Tanner Gordon (6.14 ERA) on the mound, both starters have struggled to suppress runs—especially in hitter-friendly environments like Denver.
The Rockies have allowed a staggering 6.43 ERA over their last 10 games, while Miami enters with a .271 team batting average and has hit the over in six of its last ten outings. Add in Coors Field’s notorious altitude boost to fly balls and the fact that both teams feature hot bats—Hunter Goodman (30 HR) and Mickey Moniak for Colorado, and Agustin Ramirez and Eric Wagaman for Miami—it’s easy to envision a 7–5 or 8–4 final that clears the total comfortably.
Best Bet #2
- Miami/ Colorado Over 10
An Easy Yankees Win Rounds Out Today's MLB Best Bets
The Yankees are well-positioned to cover the -1.5 run line tonight against the Orioles at Camden Yards, with Max Fried (17–5, 3.03 ERA) anchoring a rotation that’s been dominant in September. New York enters as a heavy favorite and has gone 22–11 this season when favored at -198 or shorter, while Baltimore has covered just three times in nine games when listed as a +165 underdog.
Fried’s consistency and the Yankees’ top-tier offense—led by Aaron Judge (.326 AVG, 48 HR, 103 RBI) and Cody Bellinger (28 HR)—give them a clear edge over Cade Povich (3–7, 5.05 ERA), who’s struggled against power-heavy lineups. With New York winning six of its last nine as a moneyline favorite and Baltimore just 2–4 ATS in its last six as an underdog, expect the Yankees to build an early lead and close out a 6–3 win.
Best Bet#3
- New York Yankees -1.5 (-120)
Recapping today's MLB Best Bets
- Angels/Brewers Under 8
- Miami/Colorado Over 10
- New York Yankees -1.5 (-120)
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Bet $5 & Get $200 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
