Free MLB Playoff Props For Wednesday, October 1, 2025
It’s Wednesday and Day Two of the MLB Wild Card round, and we’re coming off a solid 2-1 performance yesterday with our MLB Prop Best Bets. Today’s slate sets up with even more betting value, and we’ve locked in three of the strongest props on the board. Backed by stats, trends, and matchup analysis, these plays are built to cash.
MLB Prop Best Bet #1: No Runs First Inning Detroit/Cleveland
NRFI (No Runs First Inning) is a solid play in tonight’s Tigers-Guardians matchup, with Casey Mize and Tanner Bibee on the mound. Mize has been sharp early, posting a 1.93 ERA in the first inning across three starts, using his sinker-slider combo to induce weak contact and avoid early damage. Bibee has been more vulnerable with a 3.77 ERA in the opening frame, but he’s backed by a Cleveland defense that ranks top-10 in first-inning efficiency and has limited leadoff production.
Both lineups have been slow starters—Detroit ranks bottom-third in first-inning batting average, and Cleveland has struggled to string together early rallies. With two starters capable of settling in quickly and offenses that tend to build gradually, the NRFI offers value in what projects as a cautious, low-volatility opening frame.
MLB Prop Best Bet #2: Red Sox/ Yankees No Scoring In 1st inning
Ben Rice 2+ total bases is a strong prop play tonight, riding the momentum of his recent hot streak. Over his last 12 games, Rice is hitting .375 and consistently squaring up fastballs with gap-to-gap power. He’s posted multiple hits in five of those outings and has shown the ability to turn singles into extra bases with aggressive baserunning.
Whether it’s a pair of singles, a double, or a deep shot, Rice’s current form and plate discipline make him a threat to cash this prop early. Against a right-handed starter with middling command, Rice’s lefty bat profiles well for hard contact and run-producing opportunities.
MLB Prop Best Bet #3: Zack Littell Under 3.5 Strikeouts
Zack Littell under 3.5 strikeouts is a sharp prop for Game 2 of the Reds-Dodgers Wild Card series, especially given the elimination-game dynamics and the matchup against a disciplined Dodgers lineup. Littell has averaged just 3.3 strikeouts per start this season and has failed to reach four Ks in two of his last three outings. He’s not a high-whiff pitcher to begin with, relying more on pitch-to-contact efficiency than overpowering stuff, and that profile is a tough fit against a Dodgers team that ranks top-5 in strikeout avoidance and excels at extending at-bats.
In a win-or-go-home scenario, Cincinnati is expected to keep a short leash on Littell, especially if he faces early traffic or a rising pitch count. With the Reds likely to lean on their bullpen depth and the Dodgers grinding out plate appearances, Littell’s path to volume is limited. The under 3.5 strikeouts aligns with both game flow and managerial urgency, making it a strong lean in a high-leverage spot.
Recapping Today's MLB Prop Best Bets
- Detroit/Cleveland No Runs First Inning (-170)
- Ben Rice 2+ Total Bases (+144)
- Zack Littell Under 3.5 Strikeouts (-158)