Dallas Stars vs New York Rangers Prediction and Picks - December 2, 2025
Tuesday evening National Hockey League action, and we have a Dallas Stars vs New York Rangers prediction ready to rock and roll. The Stars enter this contest off a 6-1 home win over Ottawa. It was their 4th win in a row and Dallas is now 17-9 on the year. The Rangers come in off a 4-1 home loss to the Lightning, which dropped them to 13-14 on the year. These teams split the two meetings last year. Read on to see our Stars vs Rangers prediction.
If you’re looking to cross-check the books and put some cash in your pocket, check out our free NHL picks!
Stars Crush The Sens At Home
The Stars’ most recent game was a 6–1 win over the Ottawa Senators on November 30, where Wyatt Johnston recorded a hat trick with two power-play goals, Jason Robertson added a goal and two assists in his 400th career NHL game, and Jamie Benn chipped in with a third-period tally. Casey DeSmith made 15 saves to remain unbeaten in regulation, and Dallas limited Ottawa to just 16 shots, their lowest defensive total of the season.
Dallas has been one of the league’s most dangerous offensive teams, averaging 3.5 goals per game (3rd) while boasting the NHL’s best power play at 32.6%. Johnston and Robertson share the team lead with 16 goals each, while Mikko Rantanen has been a playmaking force with three assists in the Ottawa win. The Stars don’t generate a ton of shots (26 per game, 25th), but their efficiency and ability to capitalize on man-advantage situations make them lethal. Their faceoff win rate of 52.9% (6th) also helps them control possession and set up their attack.
Defensively, Dallas has been strong, allowing just 2.7 goals per game (7th) and limiting opponents to 27.4 shots (15th). Their penalty kill sits at 79.3% (21st), not elite but steady enough to complement their offensive firepower. With DeSmith and Jake Oettinger splitting duties in net, the Stars have depth at the position, and their ability to protect leads has been evident in their recent stretch of wins. Heading into Madison Square Garden, Dallas will look to extend their hot streak by leaning on Johnston’s scoring touch and their dominant special teams.
Sign Up for StatSalt News Alerts, Get Free Picks and Discounts
Subscribe Now
Rangers Fall To Bolts At Home
The Rangers’ most recent game was a 4–1 loss to the Tampa Bay Lightning on November 29 at Madison Square Garden, where J.T. Miller scored the lone goal for New York in the second period, assisted by Adam Fox and Mika Zibanejad. Igor Shesterkin faced a heavy workload, making 31 saves, but the Rangers were outshot 11–2 in the first period and couldn’t recover from Tampa Bay’s early surge.
Offensively, New York continues to struggle with consistency, averaging just 2.7 goals per game (28th) despite having elite talent. Artemi Panarin remains the team’s most dynamic playmaker, fresh off a four-point performance in the Thanksgiving Showdown win over Boston, while Zibanejad leads the team in goals with nine. Alexis Lafreniere and Vincent Trocheck have chipped in secondary scoring, but the Rangers’ overall shot production sits at 26.3 per game (24th). Their power play has been a bright spot at 22% (13th), and their faceoff win rate of 53.6% (4th) helps them sustain possession, though finishing has been an issue.
Defensively, the Rangers have been far stronger, allowing just 2.6 goals per game (3rd) and recording five shutouts (league-best). Shesterkin has been steady with a .908 save percentage, and Adam Fox continues to anchor the blue line with 23 assists before his recent injury. Vladislav Gavrikov has added physicality and shot-blocking, while Carson Soucy has been a reliable presence. The penalty kill sits at 80.3% (18th), solid but not elite. Against Dallas, New York will need to lean heavily on Shesterkin’s goaltending and their defensive structure to slow down the Stars’ top-ranked power play, while hoping Panarin and Zibanejad can spark enough offense to keep pace.
Dallas Stars vs New York Rangers Pick
Stars vs Rangers Moneyline Pick
- Dallas -126 (5 Units)
Dallas -126 looks like the right side because the Stars are rolling offensively and just dismantled Ottawa 6–1 in their last outing. Wyatt Johnston’s hat trick, Jason Robertson’s milestone night, and Jamie Benn’s steady production highlight how deep this team is, and their league-best 32.6% power play continues to tilt games in their favor. Even though they don’t fire a ton of shots (26 per game, 25th), their efficiency and ability to control faceoffs (52.9%, 6th) give them consistent scoring chances. With Jeremy Swayman and Jake Oettinger splitting duties in net, Dallas has the defensive backbone to complement their attack, allowing just 2.7 goals per game (7th).
The Rangers, meanwhile, have been struggling to generate offense, averaging only 2.7 goals per game (28th) despite strong possession numbers. Their defense is elite, ranking 3rd in goals against (2.6), but they’ve dropped games like the 4–1 loss to Tampa Bay where they couldn’t sustain pressure. Artemi Panarin and Mika Zibanejad remain dangerous, yet New York’s reliance on Igor Shesterkin to bail them out has been heavy. Against a Dallas team that punishes mistakes with one of the best special teams units in the league, the Stars have the edge. At -126, you’re backing a team with more scoring depth, a top-tier power play, and the momentum of a dominant win heading into MSG.
Stars vs Rangers Over/Under Pick
- Under 5.5 (4 Units)
The Under 5.5 makes sense in Stars–Rangers because both teams lean on structure and goaltending, and their recent results reflect that. Dallas may average 3.5 goals per game (3rd), but they only generate 26 shots per game (25th) and rely heavily on their power play to boost scoring. The Rangers, meanwhile, are averaging just 2.7 goals per game (28th), and their defense has been elite, allowing only 2.6 goals per game (3rd) with Igor Shesterkin recording five shutouts already. With Dallas also ranking 7th in goals allowed (2.7) and both clubs capable of slowing pace through strong faceoff play, this matchup sets up as a tight, low-event contest where special teams and goaltending dictate the flow, making the Under 5.5 a logical angle.
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Bet $5 & Get $150
