New York Islanders vs Colorado Avalanche Prediction and Picks - November 16, 2025
Use Code SSWC Sunday evening on the NHL ice, and we have a New York Islanders vs Colorado Avalanche prediction ready to rock and roll. The Islanders come in off a 3-2 OT win over Utah on the road to move to 10-8 on the year. The Avs are now at 12-6 on the year after a 6-3 home win over Buffalo. The Islanders won both meetings a year ago. Read on to see our Islanders vs Avalanche prediction.
If you’re looking to cross-check the books and put some cash in your pocket, check out our free NHL picks!
Isles Take Down Utah In OT
The Islanders roll into Denver riding a wave of confidence after a dramatic 3-2 overtime win against Utah on November 14. Emil Heineman scored in the first period, and Matthew Schaefer sealed the victory with the game-winner in OT, giving New York its fifth win in the last six games. Bo Horvat has been the offensive catalyst, tied for the league lead in goals earlier this month, while Jonathan Drouin and Jean-Gabriel Pageau have added steady production. Rookie defenseman Matthew Schaefer has been a revelation, scoring clutch goals and earning NHL Rookie of the Month honors in October.
Defensively, the Islanders have leaned on Ilya Sorokin, who posted a shutout against the Rangers on November 8 and continues to be one of the league’s most reliable goaltenders. The blue line, anchored by Adam Pelech and Ryan Pulock, has been physical but occasionally vulnerable against speed, something Colorado will test. Still, the Islanders’ ability to grind out wins on this brutal road trip has shown resilience, especially with victories over Vegas, New Jersey, and the Rangers in the past week.
Sign Up Get $30 Premium Picks Credit + Exclusive Offers
Subscribe Now
Coach Patrick Roy has emphasized structure and discipline, and the team has responded with balanced scoring and timely defense. With veterans like Anders Lee and Kyle Palmieri providing leadership, and young talent like Schaefer stepping up, the Islanders have proven they can hang with top-tier opponents. Heading into Colorado, they’ll need Sorokin sharp and Horvat active in the offensive zone to keep pace with one of the NHL’s most explosive teams.
Avs Have Won Five In A Row
Colorado enters this matchup red-hot, having won five straight, capped by a 6-3 victory over Buffalo on November 13. Martin Nečas was the star of that game, recording two goals and two assists, while Nathan MacKinnon extended his point streak to 11 games. Gabriel Landeskog added his 250th career goal, and young forward Gavin Brindley chipped in with a goal and an assist. The Avalanche have been dominant offensively, leading the league with 64 goals, and their depth has been on full display with contributions from Artturi Lehkonen, Ross Colton, and Brock Nelson.
On the back end, Cale Makar continues to be the engine, quarterbacking the power play and driving transition. Devon Toews and Josh Manson provide stability, while Brent Burns, even at 41, adds veteran presence and offensive punch from the blue line. In net, Mackenzie Blackwood has shared duties with Scott Wedgewood, giving Colorado reliable goaltending behind their high-powered attack. Defensively, they’ve allowed just 40 goals, ranking among the league’s best, which complements their relentless scoring pace.
Coach Jared Bednar has this group firing on all cylinders, blending veteran stars with emerging young talent. With MacKinnon and Nečas leading the charge, and Landeskog back healthy, the Avalanche look every bit like a Stanley Cup contender again. Facing the Islanders, Colorado will aim to use their speed and depth to break through Sorokin, while leaning on their home-ice advantage at Ball Arena to keep the win streak alive.
New York Islanders vs Colorado Avalanche Pick
Islanders vs Avalanche Moneyline Pick
- Colorado -1.5 (2 Units)
Colorado -1.5 on the puckline makes sense given how dominant the Avalanche have looked during their current win streak. They’ve scored 64 goals already this season, tops in the league, and their depth has been overwhelming for opponents. Martin Nečas has been on fire, Nathan MacKinnon continues to pile up points, and Gabriel Landeskog’s return has added another layer of leadership and scoring punch. With Cale Makar driving the transition game and Brent Burns adding veteran presence on the blue line, Colorado has the firepower and defensive balance to put pressure on the Islanders for a full 60 minutes.
The Islanders have been scrappy, but their offense has leaned heavily on Bo Horvat and Anders Lee, and they’ve struggled to consistently generate chances against elite defenses. Ilya Sorokin gives them a fighting chance in net, but Colorado’s speed and depth are a different animal, especially at Ball Arena where the Avs thrive. With the way Colorado has been finishing games and spreading the scoring across multiple lines, the puckline feels like the sharper play — the Avalanche have the tools to break through Sorokin and create separation late, covering the -1.5 with their relentless attack.
Islanders vs Avalanche Over/Under Pick
- Under 6.5 (1 Unit)
The Under 6.5 feels like a sharp angle because both the Islanders and Avalanche have leaned on strong defensive play and reliable goaltending despite their recent offensive bursts. New York has Ilya Sorokin anchoring the crease, capable of stealing games and keeping scores tight, while Colorado’s defensive core led by Cale Makar and Devon Toews has limited opponents to just 40 goals through their first stretch of the season. The Islanders tend to grind out low-event hockey, and even though Colorado has the firepower to score in bunches, facing Sorokin usually slows the pace. With both teams structured defensively and capable of controlling tempo, this matchup has the makings of a game that stays under the 6.5 total.
Never Tried Picks and Parlays? Now Is Your Chance
- Get your first daily picks package for ONLY $1 using coupon code BUCK
- If the pick loses, we credit your account with 3 Flex Picks
- If the pick wins, we still give you 1 Flex Pick on the house
- Win or lose, you walk away ahead. One dollar. No catch.
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
New Users – Bet $5 Get $200 in Bet Reset Tokens for 5 Days
