Ottawa Senators vs. Toronto Maple Leafs Prediction and Picks - December 27, 2025
The Ottawa Senators (18-13-5) head to Scotiabank Arena this Saturday for the latest installment of the "Battle of Ontario" against the Toronto Maple Leafs (16-15-5). Ottawa enters the contest as one of the hottest teams in the Atlantic Division, having won four of their last five games, including a dominant 6-2 victory over Boston. Conversely, the Maple Leafs have been a model of inconsistency, struggling to maintain a .500 record while battling a localized injury crisis in their defensive corps. With Toronto boasting a strong 11-5-5 record on home ice and Ottawa excelling on the road (10-7-2), this Saturday night showcase on ESPN+ carries significant weight for two rivals separated by just four points in the standings.
Make sure you are keeping up with all the NHL action with our free NHL Predictions.
Sign Up for StatSalt News Alerts, Get Free Picks and Discounts
Subscribe Now
Ottawa Senators Riding Vezina-Caliber Goaltending
The Senators have surged back into the playoff conversation thanks largely to the resurgence of Linus Ullmark. After a shaky start to the campaign, Ullmark has regained his Vezina form, posting a 1.85 GAA and a .928 save percentage over his last four starts. The offense is equally potent, led by Tim Stutzle, who has already racked up 39 points and 18 goals this season. The top six has been bolstered by the return of Thomas Chabot to the blue line, providing the transition play that Ottawa lacked early in December.
However, the Senators' depth is currently being tested by injuries to the center position. Shane Pinto (lower body) and Lars Eller (broken foot) remain out, forcing Ridly Greig into a larger role between the circles. For Ottawa to secure the road win, they must capitalize on their league-leading power play ($26.1\%$) against a Toronto penalty kill that has looked vulnerable during their recent three-game losing skid.
Toronto Maple Leafs Battling Defensive Depth Issues
It has been a difficult month for Craig Berube’s squad, primarily due to a depleted back end. The Maple Leafs are without shutdown defenseman Brandon Carlo, who recently underwent foot surgery, and veteran Chris Tanev, who is seeking a second opinion on an upper-body injury. This has forced heavy minutes onto Morgan Rielly and young Dennis Hildeby, who has been thrust into the starting goaltender role with Joseph Woll and Anthony Stolarz sidelined. Hildeby has shown flashes of brilliance ($2.96$ GAA), but he faces a massive challenge against Ottawa’s high-volume shooting attack.
Offensively, the "Core Four" continues to produce, with William Nylander (40 points) and John Tavares (14 goals) leading the way. The Leafs remain a dangerous home team, ranking 5th in the league in home goals per game. To snap their recent slump, Toronto will need to stay out of the penalty box and hope their high-danger scoring chances can solve a locked-in Ullmark.
Expert Picks and Predictions
Senators vs Maple Leafs Pick
Ottawa Senators +1.5
I am taking the Senators on the puck line in this rivalry matchup. While the Maple Leafs are the slight favorites at home, the situational advantages heavily favor Ottawa. The Senators have the clear edge in net with Linus Ullmark, who is playing his best hockey of the season, while Toronto is relying on a rookie backup behind a patchwork defense missing its two best shutdown blueliners. Ottawa has covered the spread in seven of their last ten road games, and in a game that usually produces tight, emotional finishes, getting the +1.5 insurance with the hotter team is the smartest play.
Senators vs Maple Leafs Total Pick
Over 6.5
I am leaning toward the Over for this Saturday night clash. Both of these teams rank in the top ten in goals per game, and their previous meetings in 2025 have been high-scoring affairs, averaging 7.2 total goals. Toronto’s defensive injuries have led to a significant increase in high-danger chances against, and even with Ullmark playing well, the firepower of Matthews and Nylander at Scotiabank Arena is hard to contain for 60 minutes. Ottawa’s power play should find success against a depleted Leafs PK, likely pushing this game into a 4-3 or 5-3 territory.
Up To $1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if your First Bet Does Not Win
Bet $5 & Get $200 in Bonus Bets Win or Lose
